So If 1.9% In One Day Isn’t A Big Deal Is 3.5% In Two Days?


Well, there’s not need to panic now.  That time has passed.  We can just hold on and enjoy the ride, because what ever comes of this is going to come of this. 

The AP sort of slips out something I wrote about yesterday.  It’s in the middle of the article.  I’ll embolden some things I think is important.

China currency falls for 2nd day after surprise devaluation

BEIJING (AP) — China’s yuan fell further Wednesday, fueling concern about a possible “currency war” if other governments fight back with their own devaluations to compete in export markets.

Shock waves from Tuesday’s 1.9 percent devaluation against the U.S. dollar, which was the yuan’s biggest change in a decade, spread through financial markets, causing stocks and Asian currencies to tumble.

Beijing said the yuan’s decline was a one-time event and part of changes aimed at making the tightly controlled currency more market-oriented. But analysts said allowing market forces free rein could drive the yuan sharply lower. Those suggestions gained ammunition when the currency slid another 1.6 percent on Wednesday.

It is very possible that we could see a 10 to 15 percent drop in the exchange rate against the U.S. dollar in the next week or two,” said Duncan Innes-Ker of The Economist Intelligence Unit in a research note.

Investors saw Beijing’s move as an effort to benefit its exporters but many economists rejected that view because global demand is weak.

The yuan’s decline was small compared with fluctuations of freely traded currencies. But after a decade of little or no movement, the change rattled financial markets and threatened to fan political tensions with Europe and the United States.

While the International Monetary Fund welcomed Beijing’s support for market forces, the change sparked complaints in Washington by lawmakers who accuse Beijing of manipulating its currency to gain a trade advantage.

“This move may also trigger a new currency war” if central banks respond by trying to depress their country’s own exchange rates, said Nicholas Teo of CMC Markets in a report.

Asian currencies declined as the lower yuan weighed on prices in markets where China is a major trader. Malaysia’s ringgit and the Indonesia rupiah plunged to their lowest levels in 17 years. The Singapore dollar, Taiwan dollar and Philippine peso fell to five-year lows.

China is exporting “deflationary pressure,” said Morgan Stanley analysts Hans Redeker, Ian Stannard and Sheena Shah in a report.

“This is not a marginal event, given China’s economic weight,” they said.

Neighboring Vietnam announced it was widening the band in which its own currency, the dong, is allowed to fluctuate each day from 1 percent to 2 percent. That would allow the dong to depreciate faster, which prompted suggestions Vietnam might be trying to help its exporters compete with Chinese goods.

On Wednesday, the Chinese central bank indicated it had no immediate plans to stop the yuan’s decline. It said the fluctuations would “converge to a reasonably stable zone” following a “short period of adaptation.”

Until now, Beijing set the yuan’s value each day based on a basket of currencies that is believed to be dominated by the U.S. dollar. That meant the yuan rose with the dollar over the past year, hurting Chinese exporters and raising the threat of politically dangerous job losses. Exports in July fell by an unexpectedly steep 8.3 percent from a year earlier.

The yuan, also known as the renminbi, is allowed to fluctuate in a band 2 percent above or below a rate set by the People’s Bank of China based on its currency basket.

The central bank said that starting Tuesday, the daily target will be based on the yuan’s closing the previous day and information from traders about currency supply and demand.

Tuesday’s change probably was the “start of an engineered depreciation,” said Mizuho Bank in a report.

China’s economic growth has slowed to an annual rate of just 7 percent, which is healthy for most countries but far below the previous decade’s double-digit pace.

China becomes the third major trader to take actions that lower the value of its currency. Initiatives by Japan and the European Union over the past two years depressed the yen and euro by wider margins than this week’s decline in the yuan.

DBS called the devaluation a “small and long-overdue adjustment that barely begins to make up for the really big moves in the dollar, euro and yen.”

Beijing’s move could complicate the U.S. Federal Reserve’s decision about when to raise interest rates that have been near zero since the 2008 global financial crisis. The Fed was expected to act later this year.

A weaker yuan would reduce the price of Chinese goods, pushing down already-low U.S. inflation of 1.3 percent. The Fed wants to be “reasonably confident” inflation is returning to its 2 percent target before raising rates.

The IMF said the latest change would have no effect on the decision about whether to add the yuan to the dollar, the euro, the yen and the British pound in the basket of currencies used to set the value of the Fund’s in-house currency, called Special Drawing Rights. …….

The currency war has been underway for years now.  That’s what the various forms of “quantitative easing” is all about.  When the US was engaged in QE, China didn’t have to worry about it because they pegged the Yuan to the Dollar.  But, we quit because the Fed believes we’re all living the high life, now, and as the article suggests, the Fed was considering going the opposite way.  Because …. well, we don’t want our sluggish economy to overheat, or something. 

Don’t get me wrong, QE is a fantastically stupid notion.  But, the rationale behind stopping the US QE was as fantastically stupid as starting it. 

In spite of the Feds best efforts, the US currency is headed towards a sweet spot!  That is to say, against much most of the world the US dollar has gained in value.  We like this because we the people have more buying power.  Now, that doesn’t mean there’s not a down-side.  There is.  Imports are then cheaper, which causes less demand for similar domestic products.  And, there’s the rub.  Global free trade evangelists have ensured a no sum gain for anyone.  If all things are equal, then, the nation with the valued currency loses jobs and economic activity, causing the currency to devalue, while the economies of the lesser valued currencies increase, causing their currencies to increase in value. 

The fact of the matter is, I don’t want to live like Vietnamese.  I don’t want to live like a common Saudi.  I don’t want to live like the average Russian.  It is only the simplest of notions to protect our own interests rather than be wedded to an ideology which has continually shown to harm our interests, for decades!

I’m not saying don’t trade with the rest of the world, by all means, we should!  But, we don’t have to.  There’s nothing the rest of the world has that we need.  The world beats a path to the US every day.  Why?  Because we’re the world’s largest consumers.  They need us a lot more than we need them.  This latest devaluation of currencies demonstrate this very fact.  China isn’t lowering their currency so they can sell to Vietnam ….. nor Egypt, nor Greece, nor Tanzania.  The US is the prize, the US is the target. 

So, we can easily afford to be discriminatory towards what we allow to be bought and sold globally.  But, this will never happen until we become more US-centric, rather than globally-centric. 

Lastly, I would note what the article noted.

because global demand is weak.

A very large contributor is the weakness of the US economy. If we did the things necessary to gain a strong US economy, so too then, would it contribute to a strengthening global economy.  That is to say, allow economics to do what they do, a net sum gain for everyone, rather than a zero sum gain for every one. 

For those wedded to free trade and refuse to understand what I said, I will simply state this, in economics, there is no thought which allows for a people to do the things we know are harmful to said people.  It’s contrary to any real economic thought. 

Oh, and yes, we are in a global recession.  

This entry was posted in Economics. Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to So If 1.9% In One Day Isn’t A Big Deal Is 3.5% In Two Days?

  1. Latitude says:

    …did we ever come out of a recession?

    I just watch the housing market down here….prices are all over the place, no rhyme or reason…and nothing is really selling…again!

    • suyts says:

      Not really. We had the natural rebound …. but, team Zero stopped it before it could do any good. We’ve been stuck in neutral ever since. But, now, I see a whole lot of weakness everywhere, including the housing market.

  2. gator69 says:

    Oh, and yes, we are in a global recession.

    I believe you mean global “depression”.

  3. DirkH says:

    “I’m not saying don’t trade with the rest of the world, by all means, we should! But, we don’t have to. There’s nothing the rest of the world has that we need. The world beats a path to the US every day. Why? Because we’re the world’s largest consumers. They need us a lot more than we need them. ”

    Not really. The Chinese could designate 320 million of their own to consume everything they produce and would then have completely replaced the American consumer. I would volunteer, given the right to pay with paper notes that I write.

    So. The real reason is that the USD and US TBonds are still the means of most trade balancing. The US helped it along by invading or destroying any country that had other ideas.

    That’s why we retreat from this system very silently, by establishing Yuan based swap lines bilaterally with China, and very slowly starve the beast.

    The US consumer will then be proven to be easily replaced by any other consumer.

  4. Lars P. says:

    “There’s nothing the rest of the world has that we need. ”
    Well not exactly. Trade should increase value for all contributors – somebody does something cheaper or better.
    For example Soyuz places? I think I read somewhere that NASA just bought some 40 places for 2018 at half a billion…

    • leftinflagstaff says:

      Sending money outside our economy helped create the need to rent space on Soyuz.

      Imagine If Saudi Arabia never got dime from us, and that money stayed here.

  5. kelly says:

    It really depends on perspective look at the AUD CNY historical rates.
    Now look at the USD CNY

    In both cases the CNY has strengthened significantly but yes the blip at the end does take out a few years of strengthening against the USD

  6. kelly says:

    A couple of percent here or there really makes no difference in my opinion think of the difference in the pricing of interest rates by the central banks PBOC 4.85% and FED 0.25%
    So based on the currency only which would include interest rates, as the main way to make money is to borrow and get a greater return I would still far prefer the US. The US is also an open market so as an investor I am far more welcome in the US than in China although both countries scare me for different reasons.

    • DirkH says:

      The problem for China is that to weaken the Yuan they must buy US treasuries (or USD’s). They don’t want that stinking paper; and constantly look for ways to get rid of it (like putting it as funding into the BRICS development bank, or exchange it for Gold, but that’s getting harder as the vaults get depleted.)

      The zero interest rates in the US mean that the US economy cannot survive higher interest rates (if they could, the companies would borrow at higher rates, making QE unnecessary which only serves to offset the collapsing credit.)

      At this point the US economy is reduced to stock buybacks with near-zero interest rate credits.

      So two possibilities:
      The Chinese bit the bullet and bought more T-Bills to support their own economy.
      Or, and I think that is more likely, they shut the trap. Weakening the Yuan further strengthens the Dollar – and weakens Oil further in USD! – killing the US energy companies and remaining export companies.

      China usually moves very slowly. This time they did a shock-and-awe move, compared to their usual speed. I don’t think that’s an accident. This is designed to create shockwaves.

      Also, the Western media frantically assure us, No, this is not a currency war – meaning IT IS full scale war!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s