That Pesky Constitution Thingy! Immigration …..


Senate Hasn’t Sent Immigration Bill to House

At a White House press conference Friday afternoon, President Obama said he was “absolutely certain” the Senate amnesty bill would pass the House if it were brought to the floor for a vote. Obama said the Republican leadership should put the bill up for a vote. The problem is, the House doesn’t have the bill. The Senate still has not delivered its bill to the House for consideration.

In the days after the Senate passed its bill, House Ways and Means Chairman David Camp pointed out that the bill is unconstitutional, in its construction. The Senate bill raises revenue by creating new taxes and fees. According to the Constitution, however, legislation that raises revenue can only be introduced first in the House. 

This creates a real dilemma for Senate backers of the bill. As my colleague Matt Boyle explained at the time:

When such a revenue-raising bill comes out of the Senate, the Speaker of the House, currently Rep. John Boehner (R-OH), can use a procedure called a “blue slip resolution” to automatically kill it on the grounds that it is unconstitutional. Stockman has been promising to attempt to kill the Senate’s bill that way and, as such, Reid has refused to send it to the House, thereby protecting the bill from being “blue slipped.” The term “blue slip,” Stockman’s office noted in a release, comes from the blue color of the paper on which a resolution is printed that returns a Senate bill back to the Senate in these situations.

This is why supporters of the Senate bill are so eager to conference with the House. They need even a simple piece of legislation on immigration to get around the constitutional problem. Conferees could strip out all the language of the House bill and substitute the Senate provisions, and the resulting bill would be constitutional. 

GOP Leadership isn’t blocking the House from voting on the Senate bill. The drafters of the original Senate bill are the ones blocking the House.

Personally, I’m of the belief that if a member of the elected bodies purposefully, and knowingly introduced legislation that they know is unconstitutional, then they have betrayed their oath of office and should be removed. 

This entry was posted in News and politics. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to That Pesky Constitution Thingy! Immigration …..

  1. kim2ooo says:

    What is it with this administration and The Constitution? It looks like they would mistakenly get it right one time.

  2. leftinbrooklyn says:

    Yep. We’re witnessing a government that has thrown out it’s instruction manual. Like a clueless dad piecing together a bike on Christmas eve. The kid is better off doing it himself.

  3. Jason Calley says:

    Two points: First. Obamacare is illegal for exactly the same reason. It was created in the Senate after the House version was defeated. The Supreme Court ruled that such a bill is authorized as a tax bill because it has tax penalties for those who do not follow it. Therefore, Obamacare is illegal.

    Second: It does not matter whether it is Constitutional or not. The Constitution is a dead letter and pretending that it is followed does not make it followed.

  4. gator69 says:

    It is time we required mandatory drug testing for ALL government employees. If the man who greets me at Walmart must submit to this, why not Skeeter & Co?

    Can you think of anyone more suspect?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s