California Demonstrates Why Soft Renewables Are A Bad Idea







From the EIA…..

The contribution towards total generation from eligible renewable resources also varies seasonally. For the dates charted above, the amount of renewable generation as a percentage of the total generation within the CAISO ranges from 8% on Oct 18, 2011 to 14% on May 9, 2011.

California is trying to achieve a 33% Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) by 2020, with eligible resources that include wind, solar, geothermal, biomass, biogas, and “small hydro”, which translates roughly as generators under 30 MW.

Now imagine what is necessary for the 33%.  4 X’s the backup generation capacity must be built to facilitate this bit of insanity.  Built, maintained, and idling energy must be wasted for this Quixotic pursuit.  And, of course, all of that backup generation must be natural gas…….  for you earth-day birthday types…… have a good fracking day.  Smile     But, even that isn’t the whole story.  Because the 8%-14% is a cumulative figure for the days.  On only a 4 day sample, we see the output peaks at about 4 gigawatts and ebbs at 1.75 gigawatts.  which, ironically, occurs during the same time of the day!  1:00 A.M.!  Below is a graph of Boston’s typical electrical usage.  I borrowed it from here.  While Boston is a unique place, their electrical consumption isn’t.  This is typical of most places.  We see in the early morning hours demand is low.  This is typically referred to as base load.  As people begin to rise and shine, we see demand increase.  There is a slight drop off as people head home from work and school and whatnot.  Then there is an incline during the hours of between 6 and 8 o’clock.  It is more noticeable during a hot summer day.  People go home, start laundry, supper, …. they turn on the TV, and AC or heater depending upon the seasons……  as people turn in for the evening, demand goes down.  Now, using the output in the graphs above, predict what plants you need to keep spinning to maintain this curve.  As much energy created by the sun catchers and whirly gigs will be wasted in anticipation of need. 


Well, at least the blackouts and extra costs will happen to the people which helped cause this insanity. I do feel sorry for the folks like AAM though…….

This entry was posted in Energy. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to California Demonstrates Why Soft Renewables Are A Bad Idea

  1. Bruce says:

    Gong to be a nice little peak on those graphs at about 6pm when Jerry’s 250,000 EV’s get home from work and plug in…hey, right at peak consumption too. Amazing!

    • suyts says:

      Yep….. well thought out plans……what a massive bit of insanity.

      • David. A. Evans says:

        Think that’s insane?
        Here in the UK they’ve announced HS2 which is a high speed rail link between London & Birmingham.
        Each train uses about 12Mw, (about 16,000hp), for most of the journey. (I suspect it peaks higher than that.)
        That’s twelve, (12), 3Mw wind turbines running at 33% average capacity, (a figure I think is too high,) but there’s a problem with that logic.
        Yesterday, the installed 4006Mw could only muster 33Mw!


        • David. A. Evans says:

          Did I forget to mention that our brand of loonies in Westminster & Whitehall have mandated that 80% of our power should be supplied by renewables (read mainly wind) by 2050?


        • suyts says:

          Yeh, I know some places are going from bad to worse. Hopefully, we can all get it turned around before financial ruin and desolation hits. The 80% is unattainable unless, the financial ruin is met.

  2. Pingback: California Demonstrates Why Soft Renewables Are A Bad Idea ... | Sustainable Energy |

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s